Ranking

selected settlements and buildings according to qualitative sustainability criteria

So that the whole range of ecological and sustainable building can be seen, the following information is available at www.sdg21.eu included both settlements that have implemented very far-reaching ecological and social principles (e.g. the Moorwiesensiedlung in Kiel-Hassee), but also projects with partly only one ecological-innovative aspect (e.g. the Solar Local Heating Project Wiggenhausen). At present, this can only be derived from the descriptions. A qualitative assessment, which is to be carried out within the framework of a Upper class seminar at the University of Karlsruhe has been developed and carried out for the projects listed on this website. The aim was to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the individual projects. However, the evaluation effort is large, which is why only some of the projects have been evaluated so far. Since the projects were evaluated in two different seminars and the evaluation matrix was further developed, the scores are not consistent. Nevertheless, they allow a ranking of the projects.

This is the underlying Evaluation matrix (Word file 140 kB)

Notice: The tables of the individual headings "Large Settlements", "Residential/Settlements" and "Buildings" can be copied in most browsers after highlighting, pasted into Word, for example, and sorted according to the headings "Total" "Ecology", etc.

Large settlements >500 residential units
Size (WE)	Project name, location	Score Type		Total from 84	Urban planning from 21	Ecology from 21	Economics from 21	Socio- culture from 21
2.000	Vauban Freiburg			75	19	17	19	21
5.000	Rieselfeld Freiburg			69	19	18	15	17
2.800	French Quarter Tübingen			30 v. 64	11 v. 16	4 v. 16	5 v. 16	10 v. 16

Residential/settlements 5 to 500 residential units
Size	Project name, location	Score Type		Total from 84	Urban planning from 21	Ecology from 21	Economics from 21	Socio-culture from 21
20	Housing and Work Freiburg			69 v. 81	17 v. 18	16 v. 21	18 v. 21	18 v. 21
21	Moorwiesensiedlung Kiel			68	19	20	15	14
110	Sheep's Broth Tübingen			66	20	17	15	14
40	Geroldsäcker Karlsruhe			65	17	19	16	13
36	Genova eG Freiburg			65	19	14	13	19
86	MIKA Karlsruhe			61	16	8	17	20
84	Arcadia Asperg			57	16	18	13	10
18	Lindenwäldle Freiburg			48	11	13	12	12
50	Schlierberg Freiburg			47	11	14	14	8
20	„On the Staig“ Donaueschingen			35 v. 64	12 v. 16	12 v. 16	3 v. 16	8 v. 16
68	„At the village“ Kirchheim Heidelberg			19 v. 64	7 v. 16	7 v. 16	1 v. 16	4 v. 16
14	Brickyard Freiburg			40	13	7	10	10
68	City & Woman Freiburg			38	11	5	8	14
180	Smiley West Karlsruhe			15 v. 64	8 v. 16	4 v. 16	-3 v. 16	6 v. 16
125	50 acres Hohenwettersbach			15 v. 64	4 v. 16	8 v. 16	3 v. 16	0 v. 16
101	Living at the Stone Path Stutensee			14 v. 64	9 v. 16	4 v. 16	2 v. 16	-1 v. 16

Building
Size	Project name, location	Score Type		Total from 75	Urban planning from 15	Ecology from 21	Economics from 21	Socio-culture from 18
200 m²	Heliotrope Freiburg			57	12	16	18	11
m²	Villa Deconstructivista  Breisach			41 v. 57	4	18	13	10
m²	Solar factory  Freiburg			33 v. 66	6	16	7 v. 18	4 v. 12
m²	Ecostation Freiburg			26 v. 54	4 v. 16	13 v. 16	5 v. 16	4 v. 8
m²	Energy self-sufficient solar house Freiburg			30	3	13	11	3

Valuation key

Contact: Holger Wolpensinger