Ranking


selected settlements and buildings according to qualitative sustainability criteria

So that the whole range of ecological and sustainable building can be seen, the following information is available at www.sdg21.eu included both settlements that have implemented very far-reaching ecological and social principles (e.g. the Moorwiesensiedlung in Kiel-Hassee), but also projects with partly only one ecological-innovative aspect (e.g. the Solar Local Heating Project Wiggenhausen). At present, this can only be derived from the descriptions. A qualitative assessment, which is to be carried out within the framework of a Upper class seminar at the University of Karlsruhe has been developed and carried out for the projects listed on this website. The aim was to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the individual projects. However, the evaluation effort is large, which is why only some of the projects have been evaluated so far. Since the projects were evaluated in two different seminars and the evaluation matrix was further developed, the scores are not consistent. Nevertheless, they allow a ranking of the projects.

This is the underlying Evaluation matrix (Word file 140 kB)

Notice: The tables of the individual headings "Large Settlements", "Residential/Settlements" and "Buildings" can be copied in most browsers after highlighting, pasted into Word, for example, and sorted according to the headings "Total" "Ecology", etc.

Large settlements
>500 residential units
Size (WE) Project name, location Score
Type
Total
from 84
Urban planning
from 21
Ecology
from 21
Economics
from 21
Socio-
culture
from 21
2.000 Vauban
Freiburg
A-DCBA level 75 19 17 19 21
5.000 Rieselfeld
Freiburg
A-DCBA level 69 19 18 15 17
2.800 French Quarter
Tübingen
B-DCBA level 30
v. 64
11
v. 16
4
v. 16
5
v. 16
10
v. 16

 

Residential/settlements
5 to 500 residential units
Size Project name, location Score
Type
Total
from 84
Urban planning
from 21
Ecology
from 21 
Economics
from 21 
Socio-culture
from 21 
20 Housing and
Work

Freiburg
A-DCBA level 69
v. 81
17
v. 18
16
v. 21
18
v. 21
18
v. 21
21 Moorwiesensiedlung
Kiel
A-DCBA level 68 19 20 15 14
110 Sheep's Broth
Tübingen
A-DCBA level 66 20 17 15 14
40 Geroldsäcker
Karlsruhe
A-DCBA level 65  17 19 16 13
36 Genova eG
Freiburg
A-DCBA level 65  19 14 13 19
86 MIKA
Karlsruhe
B-DCBA level 61  16 8 17 20
84 Arcadia
Asperg
B-DCBA level 57  16 18 13 10
18 Lindenwäldle
Freiburg
B-DCBA level 48  11 13 12 12
50 Schlierberg
Freiburg
B-DCBA level 47  11 14 14 8
20 On the Staig
Donaueschingen
B-DCBA level 35
v. 64
12
v. 16
12
v. 16
3
v. 16
8
v. 16
68 At the village
Kirchheim
Heidelberg
B-DCBA level 19
v. 64
7
v. 16
7
v. 16
1
v. 16
4
v. 16
14 Brickyard
Freiburg
C-DCBA level 40 13 7 10 10
68 City & Woman
Freiburg
C-DCBA level 38 11 5 8 14
180 Smiley West
Karlsruhe
C-DCBA level 15
v. 64
8
v. 16
4
v. 16
-3
v. 16
6
v. 16
125 50 acres
Hohenwettersbach
C-DCBA level 15
v. 64
4
v. 16
8
v. 16
3
v. 16
0
v. 16
101 Living at the
Stone Path

Stutensee
C-DCBA level 14
v. 64
9
v. 16
4
v. 16
2
v. 16
-1
v. 16

 

Building
Size Project name, location Score
Type
Total
from 75
Urban planning
from 15 
Ecology
from 21 
Economics
from 21 
Socio-culture
from 18
200 m² Heliotrope
Freiburg
A-DCBA level 57 12 16 18 11
Villa Deconstructivista 
Breisach
B-DCBA level 41
v. 57
4 18 13 10
Solar factory 
Freiburg
B-DCBA level 33
v. 66
6 16 7
v. 18
4
v. 12
Ecostation
Freiburg
B-DCBA level 26
v. 54
4
v. 16
13
v. 16
5
v. 16
4
v. 8
Energy self-sufficient solar house
Freiburg
C-DCBA level 30 3 13 11 3

Valuation key
DCBA_Key

Contact: Holger Wolpensinger